Review: Miss Saigon – Festival Theatre, Edinburgh

First published in The Times, Tuesday January 23 2017

Three Stars

Miss Saigon, the Vietnam-set musical based on Puccini’s Madam Butterfly, is the long-running proof that theatrical lightning can strike twice. Prior to its premiere in the West End in 1989, few expected Claude-Michel Schönberg and Alain Boublil to come close to the success of Les Misérables, their previous smash. Yet, despite teething problems, including controversies surrounding the casting of Caucasian actors in Asian roles, the story of a doomed love affair between a young Vietnamese woman and an American GI has proved every bit as durable as its predecessor.

In terms of spectacle, production values and performance, this UK touring production, based on the 2014 London revival and directed by Laurence Connor, is little short of impeccable. The set pieces, including the famous sequence dramatising the fall of Saigon, in which a life-sized helicopter is seen hovering over the stage, rotor blades beating, remain as thrilling as ever. The more intimate scenes are accomplished with the same attention to detail, and the whole package is elevated by Bob Avian’s diverse musical staging, shimmering orchestral playing and beautiful lighting designed by Bruno Poet.

MISS SAIGON. Ashley Gilmour 'Chris' and Sooha Kim 'Kim'. Photo Johan Persson

Pic: Johan Persson

In Red Concepción, who plays the linchpin role of the Engineer, the wily Saigon pimp who dreams of a life of excess in America, and Sooha Kim, playing Kim, the 17-year-old bargirl who falls in love with Chris (Ashley Gilmour), a young sergeant, the production boasts a couple of bona fide star turns. Concepción’s characterisation of the Engineer as a mix of rapaciousness, casual cruelty and tragic delusion is shown off to the full in the brilliantly staged final act showstopper, The American Dream, while Kim captures an appealing blend of innocence, anger and resolve in her role.

MISS SAIGON. Red Concepcion 'The Engineer' and company. Photo by Johan Persson

Pic: Johan Persson

For all of this production’s sheen, reservations remain about the content of the show. With its roots in opera (Schönberg and Boublil’s oeuvre has been referred to as “popera”), the dramatis personae rarely break free from their archetypal limits: as in Les Mis the characters begin and end the story as either good or bad. Although Connor lobs a few barbs at the United States’ culture and self-image (at one point the Engineer shouts “Make America great again!”), the show’s exhausting emotional pitch could use some leavening irony. Some musical numbers walk a fine line between sincerity and schmaltz.


All of this leads to an exasperating imbalance in the piece overall: a triumph of spectacle over substance. The ensemble works hard, the principals are strong, and the story is, at times, affecting. Nonetheless, on leaving the theatre, it is not so much the star-crossed lovers that stay in the mind but the iconic technical feat of the helicopter, roaring and whirring above the stage.


Box office: 0131 529 6000, to February 17. Touring UK to November 17

Author: Allan Radcliffe

I am a writer, freelance journalist, subeditor and theatre critic, based in South Queensferry. My short fiction has been published in anthologies such as Out There, Elsewhere, The Best Gay Short Stories, ImagiNation, Markings, Gutter, New Writing Scotland and Celtic View. I have won the Scottish Book Trust's New Writer's Award and several of my stories have been adapted for broadcast on BBC Radio 4. As a journalist I write regularly for The Times, the Scotsman, Scotland on Sunday, Sunday Herald, Sunday Times, Metro, Big Issue and I was formerly assistant editor of The List magazine.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: